Care home concerns: who to complain to and when poor care could amount to negligence

Start with the care home itself and use its complaints procedure. If that doesn’t resolve things, go to the local council if it funds the placement, and then to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which can also investigate privately funded care. Tell the Care Quality Commission too, although it doesn’t investigate individual complaints. If someone is in danger or a crime may have been committed, don’t wait for any of this. Contact the council’s safeguarding team or the police.

Poor care can amount to negligence when it falls below a reasonable standard and causes harm, such as a fall, a pressure sore or a medication error. A complaint is about getting answers and change. A negligence claim is about compensation. You can pursue both, but they work differently and the order matters.

This guide covers care homes in England.

How do you complain about a care home?

Raise it with the care home manager first, ideally in writing, and ask for a copy of the complaints procedure. Every registered care provider must have one. If you aren’t satisfied, go to the local council if it funds or arranged the care, then to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. Tell the Care Quality Commission, and call the police if you think a crime has happened.

That order is the one the Care Quality Commission sets out. It says that by law all health and social care services must have a complaints procedure, and that you should contact the provider in the first instance.

In practice it helps to start with a conversation and then put the same points in an email or letter. A written complaint gives you a date to point to and makes it harder for the issue to drift. Ask how long the home will take to reply and what the next stage is.

You can complain on someone else’s behalf if they’ve given you permission or you have a legal right to act for them, such as a lasting power of attorney.

Who handles what?

WhoWhat they doWhen to use them
Care home manager or providerInvestigates your complaint under its own procedureAlways the first step for a non urgent concern
Local councilHandles complaints about care it funds or arranged, and runs adult safeguardingWhen the council pays for the placement, or you suspect abuse or neglect
Local Government and Social Care OmbudsmanIndependently investigates complaints about councils and adult social care providers, including privately funded careAfter the home or council has had a chance to put things right
Care Quality CommissionRegulates and inspects care homes but doesn’t take forward individual complaintsTo report poor care so it can inform inspections
PoliceInvestigates crimes such as assault or theftWhen someone is in danger or a crime may have happened
SolicitorAdvises on whether poor care amounts to negligence and on a claim for compensationWhen there has been harm, such as an injury or deterioration in health

The Ombudsman won’t normally look at a complaint until the organisation has completed its own process. It says that if you haven’t had a reply within a reasonable time, which in most cases it thinks should be up to 16 weeks, you can come to it anyway.

When should you not wait for the complaints process?

If someone is in immediate danger or you suspect a crime such as assault or theft, call 999. If you believe a resident is being abused or neglected, contact the council’s adult safeguarding team straight away. You don’t have to finish the care home’s complaints procedure first, and anyone can raise a safeguarding concern.

Under section 42 of the Care Act 2014, a council has to make enquiries if it has reason to suspect that an adult with care and support needs is experiencing, or is at risk of, abuse or neglect and can’t protect themselves. The statutory guidance treats neglect and poor care practice in a setting such as a care home as a form of abuse, so a safeguarding referral isn’t limited to dramatic cases.

Most council websites have a page for reporting a safeguarding concern, and many have an out of hours number. If you aren’t sure whether your concern meets the threshold, ring and ask. A safeguarding enquiry runs alongside any complaint and doesn’t replace it.

How to write a complaint that gets a response

Keep it factual and specific. Vague complaints get vague replies.

  • Say Who Was Involved, What Happened And When
  • Describe The Harm Or Risk To The Resident
  • State Clearly What You Want The Home To Do
  • Ask For A Written Reply By A Set Date
  • Keep Copies Of Everything, Including Emails And Photos
  • Note The Names Of Staff You Spoke To And The Dates

The care records are often where the answers are. These include care plans, falls risk assessments, medication charts and daily notes. A resident can ask for their own records through a subject access request, and you can ask for them on someone else’s behalf if you have their permission or a power of attorney. Organisations usually have 1 month to respond.

If you’ve seen an injury, photograph it with a date. Write down what staff told you at the time. It’s easy to assume you’ll remember, and it’s equally easy to find a year later that you don’t.

When could poor care amount to negligence?

Poor care amounts to negligence when the home owed the resident a duty of care, failed to meet a reasonable standard of care, and that failure caused an injury or loss that wouldn’t otherwise have happened. Unhappiness or a poor experience isn’t enough on its own. You need harm, such as a fracture, an infection or a pressure sore, that can be linked to what the home did or failed to do.

A care home owes its residents a duty of care. The standard is that of a reasonably competent care provider. The fundamental standards that the Care Quality Commission inspects against are a useful reference point, but a breach doesn’t automatically make a claim.

The hard part is usually causation. Many residents are frail and have existing conditions, and some will fall or develop sores even with good care. A fall on its own isn’t negligence. The questions are whether the home knew the risk, whether it assessed and planned for it, and whether it followed its own plan. That is where the records matter.

Our care home negligence solicitors can look at those records and tell you whether the care fell below the standard and whether it caused the harm.

Examples of poor care that may lead to a claim

The situations that most often lead to care home negligence claims include medication errors, pressure sores, falls and handling errors, and neglect or abuse. The table shows what to look for in each.

ConcernWhat to look forPossible harm
Medication errorsWrong or missed doses, gaps or mistakes in medication recordsSerious illness or a hospital admission
Pressure soresResidents left in one position for long periods, dressings applied incorrectly, sores not treatedPain, infection and further treatment
Falls and handling errorsNo mobility aids, untrained staff, a resident with known mobility problems left unsupervisedFractures, head injuries and loss of independence
Neglect or abusePoor hygiene, unexplained injuries, sudden changes in mood or behaviourInjury and lasting distress
Infection control failuresNo policy to limit the spread of infection, or a policy that was ignoredSerious illness and, in the worst cases, death

Here is a simple illustration, not a real case. Imagine your relative has a known risk of falling and the care plan says they need help to walk to the bathroom. A staff member is busy and your relative tries to go alone, falls and breaks a hip. Whether that is negligence depends on whether the plan was followed, whether there were enough staff and whether the risk was properly managed. The same fall in a home that had no plan at all would look very different.

If you’re unsure whether what you’ve seen is a problem, record what you’ve noticed and speak to someone before you decide.

Time limits, capacity and claims after a death

A care home negligence claim should generally be made within 3 years of the negligence or from the date you first knew that the injury or illness was caused by it. The rules are in section 11 of the Limitation Act 1980. Don’t confuse this with the Ombudsman’s limit. The Ombudsman normally won’t look at a complaint if more than 12 months have passed since you first knew about the problem, which is much shorter.

Different rules apply in some situations. If the resident lacks the mental capacity to bring a claim, for example because of advanced dementia, the 3 years generally doesn’t start to run unless they recover capacity. Someone else, such as an attorney or a litigation friend, would normally bring the claim for them. A relative can’t simply bring it in their own name.

If the resident has died, a claim is usually brought on behalf of their estate, and the 3 years generally runs from the date of death. The person bringing the claim needs legal authority to act for the estate, so it is worth speaking to a solicitor early.

Complaint or claim: what can each one do?

A complaint can get you answers, an apology and changes to your relative’s care. A negligence claim is the route to compensation for injury and for costs such as extra care or treatment. Many problems are best solved by a complaint. A claim needs medical evidence and proof that the poor care caused the harm, so it isn’t the right tool for every concern.

The two can overlap, and the order matters. The Ombudsman says it can’t normally look into a complaint if you’re already taking legal action, or if another process, such as a court, is better suited to putting the problem right. If you think you may want to claim, speak to a solicitor before you start an Ombudsman complaint so you don’t close off an option by accident.

Keep every reply you receive from the home or the council. Those letters can become part of the evidence, even if you never expected to need them.

Funding a claim and other legal help

Most care home negligence claims proceed on a no win no fee basis under a conditional fee agreement. If your claim succeeds you pay fees from the compensation, and if it doesn’t you aren’t liable for fees. We will explain exactly how costs work before you decide to go ahead.

A concern about a care home can also raise other legal questions.

Frequently asked questions

Who do you complain to if the care home won’t listen?

If the council funds the placement, complain to the council. If you pay for the care yourself, or the council’s response doesn’t resolve things, you can complain to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which investigates privately funded care too. Also tell the Care Quality Commission, and contact the police if a crime may have happened.

Can you complain to the CQC about a care home?

Yes, you can tell the Care Quality Commission about poor care, and it encourages you to. It doesn’t take forward individual complaints on your behalf, but the information helps it decide when and where to inspect. You should still complain to the home or council to get your own concerns resolved.

Can you sue a care home for neglect?

Yes, if the home failed to provide a reasonable standard of care and that caused injury or loss. Pre existing conditions can make the cause harder to prove, so records and medical evidence matter. A solicitor can tell you whether you have a realistic claim and whether it is worth pursuing.

How long do you have to complain about a care home?

There is no fixed limit for complaining to the home, but do it promptly. The Ombudsman normally won’t look at a complaint more than 12 months after you first knew about the problem. A negligence claim generally has a 3 year limit, with exceptions for people who lack capacity and for claims after a death.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

If you’re worried about the care your relative has received and you’re not sure whether it amounts to negligence, speak to us. Call us on 0800 002 9577 or contact our team for a free, no obligation chat. We know these cases can be upsetting, so we deal with every aspect with sensitivity and keep your conversations confidential. We have offices in Liverpool, Leigh, Runcorn and Warrington.

Who keeps the pension in a divorce: sharing, offsetting and earmarking explained

Your ex-partner doesn’t automatically get a share of your pension when you divorce, and you don’t automatically keep it either. A pension is treated as a financial asset, like the house or your savings, and there are 3 main ways to deal with it. A pension sharing order moves a percentage of the pension into a separate pension for your ex. Offsetting lets one of you keep the pension in return for other assets. Earmarking, also called attachment, gives your ex a share of the payments when the pension is eventually paid. Sharing and earmarking both need a court order, and the right choice depends on the size of the pensions, your ages and what else is in the pot.

This guide covers England and Wales. It explains how each method works, which pensions count and what to check before you agree anything.

Are pensions part of a divorce?

Yes. Pensions count as financial resources in a divorce, and for many couples they are the biggest asset after the family home. You and your ex can agree how to divide them, or the court can decide. Ignoring them is a common and costly mistake, because a pension can be worth more than the home you’re arguing over.

In England and Wales the court can take into account the total value of the pensions you’ve each built up, not only the part built up during the marriage. How much is shared depends on your circumstances, including how long you were together, your ages, your needs and what other assets there are.

GOV.UK explains that you and your ex need to agree how to divide pensions, property, savings and investments, and that an agreement needs a consent order to make it legally binding. If you weren’t married or in a civil partnership, different rules apply and pension sharing isn’t available.

What is a pension sharing order?

A pension sharing order is a court order that moves a percentage of one person’s pension into a separate pension in the other person’s name. It’s a permanent split, so each of you ends up with your own pension and no ongoing link. Only a court can make one, usually as part of a financial consent order or a financial remedy order.

The order states a percentage rather than a sum, and the pension scheme applies it to the value at the time the order is put into effect. The share can be transferred into a pension in your name or, in some cases, you can join your ex’s scheme. You can’t draw on it until you reach the age at which that pension can be taken.

The share can only take effect once the divorce itself has been finalised with the final order. After the scheme has the order and the right paperwork, it usually has 4 months to put it into effect. Schemes can charge for the work, so ask early who will pay.

Here is a simple illustration. Imagine your pension has a cash equivalent transfer value of £200,000 and your spouse’s is £20,000. Sharing 45% of yours would move £90,000, leaving each of you with £110,000. In real cases the figures depend on the type of pension and what else is being divided.

How does pension offsetting work?

Offsetting means one of you keeps your whole pension and the other receives other assets of equivalent value, usually a bigger share of the equity in the home or a cash sum. It can suit couples where the family home is the main asset or where a pension is too small to be worth splitting.

You and your ex can agree to offset pensions without a court order for the pension itself, but you should still record the whole settlement in a consent order, because that’s what makes it binding.

The difficulty is value. Pound for pound swaps rarely work. Cash or housing equity can be used now, while a pension can’t be touched until the minimum pension age and is generally taxed as income when you draw it. For a final salary type scheme, the headline figure can also be misleading. A fair offset usually needs more than a simple one for one calculation, and that’s where expert advice earns its fee.

What is pension earmarking?

Earmarking, also called a pension attachment order, leaves the pension with its owner. When the pension starts to be paid, a set part of the income, the lump sum or both goes to your ex. A court has to make the order, and you can’t receive anything until your ex actually starts taking their pension.

That’s the weakness. You depend on your ex retiring when it suits you, and the payments can stop in certain events, such as your ex dying or you remarrying. It also keeps your finances tied to theirs. For these reasons it’s now used less often than sharing.

If your ex has already retired, other options exist. A deferred pension sharing arrangement lets a share transfer at a later date, and a deferred lump sum gives you a payment from the pension when your ex retires. These can be more complicated to arrange, so legal costs can be higher.

Sharing, offsetting and earmarking compared

MethodHow it worksCourt order neededClean breakMain drawback
Pension sharingA percentage moves into a separate pension for your exYesYes for the pensionReduces the holder’s retirement income and the scheme may charge fees
OffsettingOne of you keeps the pension and the other takes other assetsNot for the pension alone, but the whole deal should be in a consent orderYesHard to value fairly, and cash is not worth the same as a pension
EarmarkingA share of the pension payments goes to your ex when they startYesNoDepends on your ex retiring, and payments can stop in some situations

Which pensions can be divided, and how are they valued?

Most pensions can be taken into account.

  • Workplace Pensions, Including Public Sector Schemes
  • Defined Contribution Pensions Where You Build A Pot
  • Defined Benefit Or Final Salary Pensions Based On Your Pay
  • Personal Pensions
  • Additional State Pension Built Up Before 2016

The basic State Pension and the new State Pension can’t be shared. The court can however decide that any Additional State Pension is shared as part of the settlement, and you will need to apply for a State Pension forecast on divorce using form BR20.

Pensions are usually valued using the cash equivalent transfer value, which is what you would get if you moved the pension elsewhere. It can be lower than the fund value because it includes transfer charges, and only the pension holder can ask for it. The annual statement is a free starting point. For defined benefit schemes the figure rarely reflects the true value, so the MoneyHelper guidance recommends specialist help from an actuary or a financial adviser who works on divorce cases.

That expert is often called a pension on divorce expert. You pay for the report, so ask about the cost first. For larger or more complicated pensions it is usually money well spent, because a wrong valuation can skew the whole settlement.

What to do before you agree a pension settlement

These steps help whichever method you end up using.

  • List Every Pension You And Your Ex Have, Including Old Ones
  • Ask Each Scheme For A Transfer Value And A Copy Of Its Rules
  • Request A State Pension Forecast For Divorce
  • Check Whether A Pension On Divorce Expert Report Is Needed
  • Think About Your Income In Retirement, Not Only Today’s Fairness
  • Get Advice Before You Sign A Consent Order

Old pensions are the ones that get missed. People change jobs, schemes merge and paperwork goes astray, so it is worth tracing every pension on both sides before you negotiate. In court proceedings you each give full financial disclosure, and that should include all of them.

The other trap is looking only at today. A split that looks equal on paper can leave one of you with far less income in retirement, especially if one pension is a final salary scheme and the other is a pot of savings. A divorce solicitor who deals with pensions regularly will know when an expert report is worth commissioning and when it isn’t.

Common pitfalls and what may change

A few mistakes come up repeatedly in pension settlements.

The first is relying on a transfer value alone for a defined benefit pension. The second is treating £1 of pension as equal to £1 of cash. The third is agreeing a deal informally and never turning it into a court order, which leaves it open to challenge because an agreement between you isn’t binding until a court approves it.

Timing matters too. Try to sort the financial order out before or alongside the divorce rather than leaving it until afterwards. If you remarry before getting a financial order, you can lose the right to apply for one.

The law may change. The Ministry of Justice published a consultation called A fairer end to relationships on 5 June 2026, and it closed on 14 August 2026. It proposes reforming financial remedies on divorce, including legally binding qualifying nuptial agreements. A consultation isn’t law, so the rules in this guide still apply unless and until Parliament changes them.

Funding your divorce and other legal help

We understand that legal costs are a worry at a difficult time. Our family team can offer a fixed fee for divorce matters and for finalising your financial agreement through a clean break financial consent order, so you know the cost before you start. You can read more about our family law solicitors and the support we offer.

A divorce can also raise other legal questions.

Frequently asked questions

How is a pension split in a divorce?

There are 3 main methods. A pension sharing order moves a percentage into a separate pension for your ex. Offsetting lets you keep the pension and give up other assets. Earmarking gives your ex a share of the payments when the pension starts. Sharing and earmarking need a court order, and the right method depends on the pension type, your ages and the other assets.

What percentage of a pension does a spouse get?

There’s no fixed percentage. The court starts from fairness and often looks at what each of you will need in retirement, taking into account the length of the marriage, your ages and the other assets. An equal split of the pension built up during the marriage is a common starting point, but it isn’t automatic.

Can my ex claim my pension after the divorce?

Possibly. If pensions weren’t dealt with in a final financial order, an application can usually still be made after the divorce, unless a clean break order has already ended financial claims or the person applying has since remarried. Leaving it open is risky, so it is better to deal with pensions at the same time.

How long does a pension sharing order take?

The order can only take effect once the divorce is finalised. After that, the pension scheme usually has 4 months from receiving the order and the right paperwork to put it into effect. Valuations and negotiations before that point can take much longer, particularly for final salary pensions.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

If you’re separating and aren’t sure what to do about a pension, speak to us before you agree anything. Call us on 0800 002 9577 or contact our team for a free, no obligation consultation. We have offices in Liverpool, Leigh, Runcorn and Warrington.

Not told about the risks before surgery: when a signed consent form is not enough

A signed consent form doesn’t automatically mean you gave informed consent. Under the Supreme Court’s ruling in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board, your surgeon has to take reasonable care to make sure you know about the material risks of the operation and any reasonable alternatives, including doing nothing. If that didn’t happen and a risk you weren’t told about then caused you harm, you may have an informed consent negligence claim, even if the surgery itself was carried out properly. You also need to show that you would have decided differently if you’d been told, and the 3 year time limit applies.

This guide covers England and Wales. It explains what the law requires, how to tell a known complication from a failure to warn, what you have to prove and what to do next.

What does informed consent mean in law?

Informed consent means you agreed to treatment after being told what it involves, the material risks and the reasonable alternatives, and you were free and able to decide for yourself. The test comes from the Supreme Court’s decision in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board, which ended the old approach of leaving it to doctors to decide how much patients should hear.

Before Montgomery, a doctor’s decision about what to tell you was judged mainly by what a responsible body of doctors would have said. Since 2015 the question is what you needed to know to make your own decision.

The court said a risk is material if a reasonable person in your position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the doctor knows or should reasonably know that you in particular would. It also said materiality can’t be reduced to percentages. A rare risk can matter a great deal if the consequence is severe or if it threatens something you rely on, like your hands, your sight or your ability to work.

Does a signed consent form protect the surgeon?

Not on its own. A signed form is evidence that a conversation took place, but it says little about what was said. In Montgomery, the Supreme Court held that a doctor’s duty isn’t met by routinely asking for a signature. What matters is whether you were given information you could understand about the risks and alternatives, and enough time to think about it.

The General Medical Council’s guidance on decision making and consent has applied since 9 November 2020 and was updated on 13 December 2024. It treats consent as an ongoing conversation rather than a single event, and it expects doctors to record that conversation in your notes. Surgeons’ own professional guidance makes a similar point, that a form shows a discussion happened but not how good it was.

Forms tend to be weak evidence in a few familiar situations. The form was signed on the day of surgery with little time to ask questions. The risks are listed in general terms, such as infection or bleeding, without the specific risk that later affected you. Or the person who took your consent couldn’t properly discuss your operation. None of these automatically means negligence, but each gives a solicitor something to look at.

What counts as a material risk, and what else should you have been told?

A material risk is one a reasonable person in your position would want to know about, or one your surgeon knew or should have known matters to you. Your surgeon should also have discussed reasonable alternatives, including non-surgical options and having no treatment, and what could happen if you went ahead or if you didn’t.

The NHS describes valid consent as voluntary, informed and given by someone with capacity. Informed means being told about the benefits and risks, the reasonable alternatives and what happens if treatment doesn’t go ahead. In a good consent discussion you would expect the following.

  • What The Procedure Involves And Why It Is Recommended
  • The Material Risks, Including Rare But Serious Ones
  • Reasonable Alternatives, Including No Treatment
  • Any Risks That Are Specific To Your Health Or Circumstances
  • Who Will Carry Out The Procedure
  • Enough Time To Think Before You Decide

Your own circumstances change what is material. The Supreme Court relied on an Australian case where a patient was already blind in 1 eye and faced a small risk of losing the sight in the other. A warning that is routine for one patient can be vital for another, particularly if the risk threatens your job or your independence.

What do you need to prove?

ElementWhat it meansExample
DutyYour doctor had to take reasonable care to make sure you knew about material risks and reasonable alternativesA planned operation with a recognised risk of nerve damage
BreachThe risk or alternative wasn’t properly explained, or was raised too late or too vaguelyA generic form listing complications with no real discussion
CausationIf properly told, you would have decided differently, for example by declining, choosing an alternative or delaying to get another opinionYou would have tried physiotherapy or injections first
InjuryThe risk you weren’t told about happened and you suffered harmPermanent nerve damage after the operation

The causation step is where many claims are won or lost. Your own evidence about what you would have done carries weight, and it needs to fit with the records and the rest of your account. In Correia v University Hospital of North Staffordshire NHS Trust, the Court of Appeal pointed out that the claimant had never said she would have declined or deferred the operation, and that was a problem for her consent argument.

Courts have sometimes taken a more flexible approach where a patient says they wouldn’t have refused outright but would have delayed surgery or sought another opinion. That follows Chester v Afshar, where the House of Lords allowed a narrow departure from the usual causation rules. Whether it helps you depends on the facts.

It is also possible to win on consent and lose on technique. In Thefaut v Johnston [2017] EWHC 497 (QB), the High Court found for the patient on informed consent but not on negligent performance of the surgery.

Is it a known complication or a negligent failure to warn?

Both can be true at once. A complication can be well recognised and still be something you should have been told about. The question is whether the risk was material to you and whether it was properly explained. If you were warned and chose to go ahead, a known complication usually isn’t negligence. If you weren’t warned, you may have a claim.

Here is a simple illustration, not a real case. Imagine you’re offered spinal surgery for back pain. The surgeon mentions infection and bleeding but doesn’t mention a small risk of permanent nerve damage, or that you could try injections and physiotherapy first. You’re left with lasting nerve damage. The operation was carried out competently. If a reasonable person in your position would have wanted to know about the nerve risk and the alternatives, and you would have tried them first, the missing conversation can be the basis of a claim.

The reverse also happens. If your surgeon explained the risk clearly, gave you time to decide and recorded it, a bad outcome alone doesn’t create a claim. A specialist medical negligence solicitor can review your records and tell you which of these situations you’re in, before you spend time or money on it.

What to do if you think you weren’t warned

These steps help whether or not you end up making a claim.

  • Write Down What You Remember Being Told And When
  • Request Your Medical Records And The Signed Consent Form
  • Keep Any Patient Leaflets Or Letters You Were Given
  • Note Who Else Was At The Consultation
  • Keep A Record Of Your Symptoms And Treatment Since The Operation
  • Speak To A Solicitor Before The Time Limit Runs Out

Write your account down early. These cases often turn on what was said in a short conversation, and memories fade. Anyone can ask for their medical records through a subject access request, and organisations usually have 1 month to respond. A solicitor can also ask for them on your behalf.

A complaint to the hospital or PALS can run alongside a legal claim and can be a useful source of answers. It doesn’t stop the time limit running, so don’t wait for the outcome before you take advice.

How long do you have to claim?

Generally 3 years from the date of the treatment, or from the date you first knew you had a significant injury that could be attributed to it, if that is later. The rules are in section 11 of the Limitation Act 1980. The court can sometimes allow a late claim, but it uses that discretion rarely and you shouldn’t plan around it.

Different rules apply in some situations. For a child, the 3 years doesn’t start until their 18th birthday. If the patient lacks the mental capacity to bring a claim, time generally doesn’t start to run until they recover it. If the patient has died, proceedings usually need to start within 3 years of the date of death.

Because records need to be gathered and expert evidence obtained before a claim can be issued, it is sensible to take advice well before the deadline.

Funding your claim and other legal help

Medical negligence claims need expert evidence, which makes them more involved than most injury claims. We can normally act on a no win no fee basis, and we will explain in writing how fees and costs work before you decide whether to go ahead.

A failed operation can raise other questions too.

Frequently asked questions

Can you sue a doctor for lack of informed consent?

Yes, if you can show you weren’t told about a material risk or a reasonable alternative, that you would have decided differently if you had been, and that the risk then caused you harm. The claim is brought in negligence. A signed form doesn’t prevent it, although the discussion recorded in your notes will be closely examined.

What is the difference between a consent claim and a negligent surgery claim?

A negligent surgery claim says the operation was carried out below a reasonable standard. A consent claim says you weren’t given the information you needed to decide whether to have it. They are separate arguments, and a claim can succeed on 1 and fail on the other.

Does a very small risk have to be mentioned?

Possibly. The Supreme Court said materiality can’t be reduced to percentages. A small risk of a severe or life changing outcome can still be material, especially if it matters to your work or daily life. The answer depends on the risk, the consequence and what your surgeon knew about you.

Can I change my mind after signing a consent form?

Yes. You can withdraw consent at any point before the procedure, even after you have signed. If you were pressured to go ahead or weren’t given the time you needed, tell your care team and keep a note of what was said.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

If you think you weren’t told about the risks or alternatives before surgery, speak to us before the time limit becomes a problem. Call us on 0800 002 9577 or contact our team for a free, no obligation chat. Our medical negligence team is based in our Warrington office, and we’re happy to meet you at home or at our Leigh, Liverpool or Runcorn offices.

Injured at work when your employer is uninsured or has closed down: how a claim can still work

Yes, you can usually still claim. Your right to compensation comes from your employer’s negligence, not from their insurance policy. If the business has no cover, the claim goes against the employer directly. If it has closed down, the insurer that covered it when you were injured can often be pursued instead. If that insurer has also collapsed, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme may step in. Some routes are more dependable than others, and the 3 year time limit keeps running while you work out which one applies to you.

This guide explains how each situation works, how to find out who was insured and what to do first. You don’t need the answers before you get advice. Working out who is liable and who can actually pay is a large part of what a solicitor does in these cases.

Does your employer have to have insurance?

Almost always, yes. Employers must hold Employers’ Liability insurance covering at least £5 million, bought from an authorised insurer. They can be fined £2,500 for every day they are not properly insured. The main exceptions are businesses that only employ close family members or people based outside England, Scotland and Wales.

Your employer should also display the certificate where staff can see it, for example on a noticeboard, an intranet or a website. They can be fined £1,000 if they don’t. If you’ve never seen one, ask for a copy in writing. A refusal or a vague answer tells you something, although it isn’t proof that no policy exists.

It works the other way too. A certificate on the wall doesn’t prove the policy was valid on the day you were hurt, so don’t treat it as the final word.

Can you claim if your employer has no insurance?

Yes. Your claim depends on showing your employer failed to keep you reasonably safe and that this caused your injury. If there is no insurance, the claim is brought against the employer itself. The practical question is whether they can pay, which is why the employer’s finances matter from the start.

Think of insurance as the way a claim is usually paid, not the reason it exists. A sole trader is personally responsible for the compensation. With a limited company, the company’s assets are what’s available, and directors are not usually personally liable for its debts.

Road accidents have the Motor Insurers’ Bureau, which compensates people hurt by uninsured drivers. There is no equivalent fund of last resort for uninsured employers. That gap is the main reason these claims can be harder than they should be.

Here is a simple example. Imagine you work as a labourer for a small building firm that never bought a policy, and you fall through an unprotected opening on site. The firm may have little money, but it may not be the only business involved. A main contractor, the site owner or an equipment supplier may share responsibility and may have their own insurance. A solicitor will look at all of them before deciding where to aim the claim.

What if your employer has closed down or gone into liquidation?

Closing a business doesn’t wipe out your claim. If your employer held Employers’ Liability insurance when you were injured, the Third Parties (Rights against Insurers) Act 2010 lets you pursue the insurer directly where the company is insolvent. You still have to prove your employer was at fault, but the business doesn’t need to be trading.

The first job is finding the insurer. The Employers’ Liability Tracing Office runs a database that lets injured people and their solicitors trace which insurer covered an employer, even when the cover was many years ago. You can start at the Employers’ Liability Tracing Office website, and a solicitor can usually run the search for you. A match is a starting point, not a guarantee that the policy will respond to your claim.

Some businesses close and reopen under a new name. That doesn’t automatically leave the old liability behind. Your solicitor will check which company employed you on the day of the accident and which policy was live at that time.

What if the insurer has failed too?

If the insurer has collapsed, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme can step in. It pays valid employers’ liability claims in full, as long as the insolvency practitioner dealing with the failed insurer accepts them. It can take a while, but it is a genuine safety net for this type of claim.

Which route applies to you?

Your situationWho may payWhat usually happens next
Employer still trading and insuredThe employer’s insurerThe claim is made against the employer and handled by the insurer
Employer still trading but uninsuredThe employer directlyYour solicitor checks the employer’s assets and whether anyone else shares responsibility
Employer in liquidation or dissolved, but insured when you were hurtThe employer’s insurerThe insurer is traced and pursued directly under the 2010 Act
Employer closed and the insurer has failedThe Financial Services Compensation SchemeThe claim is put to the insolvency practitioner and accepted claims are paid in full
Employer closed and no insurance can be foundPossibly nobodyYour solicitor looks for other responsible parties, but recovery may not be possible

What to do first

These steps protect your position whatever the insurance turns out to be.

  • Report The Accident And Make Sure It Is Recorded
  • Ask To See The Employers’ Liability Certificate In Writing
  • Keep Anything That Shows Who Employed You And Who Gave You Instructions
  • Photograph The Scene If It Is Safe And Note Witness Names
  • Get Medical Treatment And Keep Every Record And Receipt
  • Speak To A Solicitor Before Signing Anything Or Accepting Cash

The last point matters more than it looks. If an employer tells you they have no insurance and offers a small sum to leave it there, you could be giving up a claim worth far more. A solicitor can check the insurance position for you before you decide.

Who else might be responsible?

Many workplace injuries involve more than 1 business. If you work through an agency, the agency or the business directing your work may carry responsibility. If you’re self-employed or a subcontractor, the question is usually who controlled the site, the equipment and the safety arrangements. Your job title doesn’t settle it. The facts do.

This is one reason it helps to speak to specialist accident at work solicitors early. Bring contracts, payslips, messages containing instructions and anything that shows who was in charge on the day.

Time limits and benefits

In England and Wales you generally have 3 years from the date of the accident, or from the date you first knew your injury was significant and linked to the accident, to start court proceedings. The rules sit in section 11 of the Limitation Act 1980. Different rules can apply to children and to people who lack the mental capacity to bring a claim.

Your employer closing down doesn’t pause that clock. Starting a personal injury claim sooner also means records, witnesses and insurer details are easier to find.

Separately from compensation, Industrial Injuries Disablement Benefit may be available if you became ill or disabled because of an accident at work. The amount depends on your circumstances, and it is worth checking while your claim is in progress.

A realistic view of recovery

A court judgment against an employer with no money doesn’t pay anything. That is the uncomfortable side of uninsured claims, and a good solicitor will tell you so early. They will look at the employer’s finances, any other responsible parties and the chance of a successful insurer trace before you commit time and energy.

Sometimes the honest advice is that a claim against the employer alone isn’t worth running. More often there is a route worth exploring, and it is better to find out sooner than later.

We act on a no win no fee basis. We will explain in writing exactly how fees and costs work before your claim starts.

Other legal help that can follow a serious workplace injury

A workplace injury can raise questions beyond the claim itself.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue my employer if they have no insurance?

Yes. Your claim is based on your employer’s negligence, so a missing policy doesn’t remove it. The claim is made against the employer directly, and the question becomes whether they can pay. A solicitor can check their finances and whether anyone else shares responsibility before you decide how to proceed.

How do I find out whether my employer had insurance?

Ask for the Employers’ Liability certificate in writing, then have a solicitor search the Employers’ Liability Tracing Office database for the policy that applied when you were injured. If your employer won’t cooperate, say so when you get advice, because there are other ways to establish the position.

Can I claim if I’m self-employed or an agency worker?

Possibly. Employers’ Liability insurance is aimed at employees, so a claim usually turns on who controlled your work and the site. For agency workers that can be the agency or the business directing the work. For self-employed people it is often a main contractor or site owner. A solicitor needs to look at the facts.

Does a company going into liquidation end my claim?

No. If the company held Employers’ Liability insurance when you were injured, you can usually pursue the insurer directly under the Third Parties (Rights against Insurers) Act 2010. You still need to prove fault, and you should act well within the 3 year limit.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

If you were hurt at work and you’ve been told there’s no insurance, or the business has shut, don’t assume the claim is over. Call us on 0800 002 9577 or contact our team for a free, no obligation conversation. We act for clients from our offices in Liverpool, Leigh, Runcorn and Warrington, and we take instructions across the country.

What families should know when a loved one has a brain injury after an accident

A brain injury can affect everyone in a family. Changes in memory or behaviour may be invisible but still disrupt everyday life. Relatives may need to arrange rehabilitation and care, manage finances and establish who can make decisions. If negligence caused the accident, compensation may help fund essential ongoing support. Families also need clear information about how recovery can change over time and where to seek help.

How a brain injury can change someone

No two brain injuries have identical effects. Families may notice profound fatigue, difficulties with memory or concentration, and problems planning, starting or completing familiar tasks. Others experience headaches, sensory difficulties or behavioural changes. Symptoms can fluctuate, sometimes requiring lengthy rehabilitation.

These difficulties can be especially distressing when someone looks physically recovered but struggles with activities they previously managed easily. Friends may expect a quick recovery. Behavioural and cognitive difficulties can result from the injury, rather than a lack of effort or concern for others. Understanding this helps families adapt while respecting their loved one.

Looking after yourself, too

Caring for someone after a serious brain injury can be physically and emotionally demanding. Some relatives experience sadness for the life they expected, even while their loved one remains present and valued. Others face exhaustion and financial worries. These reactions vary, and there is no single right way to respond. Accept help, rest when possible and consider counselling or a local carers’ support group. Your wellbeing matters to sustainable care. Taking regular breaks can make it easier to respond calmly when care needs change unexpectedly.

Practical and emotional support available

Headway, the UK brain injury association, offers a free, confidential helpline on 0808 800 2244, open Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Its nurse-led team supports survivors, relatives and carers. Local Headway groups may offer practical support, activities and opportunities to meet others. Its Emergency Fund can provide eligible families and friends with up to £300 for essential travel or accommodation during hospital treatment, subject to eligibility.

If caring responsibilities mean reducing your employment, check whether you qualify for Carer’s Allowance. Eligibility generally includes providing at least 35 hours of care weekly, the injured person receiving a qualifying disability benefit, and meeting other eligibility rules. It is separate from compensation. A council carer’s assessment may identify other support.

If your family member can no longer manage their own affairs

A severe injury may affect the ability to manage bank accounts, understand contracts or consent to treatment. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 presumes adults have capacity unless established otherwise, and capacity is assessed for each decision when it must be made. A spouse, parent or adult child does not automatically acquire general authority to manage another adult’s finances simply because they are related. Some care decisions can nevertheless be made without deputyship.

A registered Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) may allow a chosen attorney to act within its terms. Financial powers may be used once registered, with permission, while welfare powers operate only when capacity is lacking. An LPA can be made after an accident if the person still has capacity. If they cannot make an LPA and ongoing financial decisions require formal authority, a Court of Protection deputyship may be appropriate. Alternatives include one-off orders or benefits appointees. Health and welfare deputyships are less commonly granted.

Lasting Power of AttorneyCourt of Protection deputyship
When it can be set upWhile the person has capacity to make an LPA, including after an injuryWhen the person lacks capacity for decisions requiring ongoing authority
Who chooses the decision makerThe person granting the LPAThe court, sometimes appointing a relative or professional
Typical timescaleRegistration usually takes eight to ten weeks if straightforwardOften several months, depending on the application

A property and financial affairs deputy may be needed to manage compensation or substantial expenditure, but their authority is court-limited. Welfare decisions can involve separate arrangements. Importantly, managing a personal injury claim may instead require appointment as a litigation friend, which is a different legal role. GOV.UK’s guidance on becoming a deputy explains the options and application process.

How a compensation claim can help fund the practical side

If someone else’s negligence caused the injury, whether in a road collision, a fall or an accident at work, a successful claim may include more than damages for the injury itself. Depending on the evidence, compensation can cover rehabilitation, therapies, case management, specialist equipment, accommodation adaptations, lost earnings and professional care. Necessary care provided without payment by family members or friends can also be valued, where it exceeds ordinary family assistance. A care diary helps establish those needs.

The long-term effects of a brain injury can take time to understand, so claims should not be settled before appropriate medical and care evidence is available. Where liability is admitted, or the court’s requirements are met, interim payments may fund urgent rehabilitation or support before final settlement. Funding is not guaranteed. Our guide to how the personal injury claim process works explains the process.

Time limits and funding

For adults in England and Wales, the usual period for starting personal injury court proceedings is three years from the accident or relevant date of knowledge. If the injured person lacked capacity to conduct the claim when the right arose, different limitation rules may apply, potentially giving three years after capacity returns. Injury does not automatically suspend limitation. Eligible claims can proceed on a no win no fee basis. If your claim isn’t successful, you won’t pay us anything. If it is successful, our fee is 20% plus VAT (24% in total), taken from the compensation you receive for your pain and suffering and for financial losses up to settlement. We never take a fee from compensation for future losses, such as future care or loss of earnings, and nothing else is deducted from your compensation. We’ll confirm all of this in writing before your claim starts.

Frequently asked questions

Common concerns raised by families include the following.

Can I make a claim on my loved one’s behalf if they can’t manage their own affairs?

Yes. An appropriate person may act as a litigation friend for someone who lacks capacity to conduct proceedings. A deputy or attorney may have separate financial responsibilities, and protected-party settlements require court approval.

Do I need a deputyship straight away?

Not always. It depends on which decisions are needed and whether an LPA, benefits appointee or one-off court order is sufficient. Seek advice early when financial decisions arise; applications can take months.

Can I claim for the care I provide myself?

Unpaid care from relatives or friends may be included in the injured person’s compensation claim where it is reasonably needed because of the injury. Keep a record of the care.

What if we don’t know yet how much our loved one will recover?

This is common. Specialists may need time to assess long-term needs, so settlements should not be rushed. Interim funding may be available in appropriate cases during rehabilitation.

Is Headway only for the person who was injured?

No. Its helpline supports families and carers as well as survivors, and local groups offer peer support.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

Supporting someone after a brain injury can involve difficult decisions about care, finances and the future. Mark Reynolds Solicitors can explain the legal process, help establish suitable authority where necessary and assess whether rehabilitation and family care costs belong in a claim. We act under the no win no fee terms explained above. Contact our team for a free, no-obligation conversation. Our offices are in Liverpool, Runcorn and Warrington, and we support clients nationally.

When Police Power Is Abused: Why Speaking Out Matters Lynne Hughes, Senior Solicitor, Mark Reynolds Solicitors

When an individual experiences police misconduct, the impact extends far beyond that person. Police officers hold significant authority, empowered by legislation to arrest, search, detain, and enter private property. However, when these powers are abused whether through unlawful arrest, unlawful stop and search, excessive force, or illegal entry the trust of the legal system relies on affected individuals coming forward. 2024/ 25 saw an all time high in the number of complaints logged against the police at 94,940. Of those, 32,172 complaints were formally recorded under statutory legal frameworks to be investigated or formally resolved.



Reporting misconduct and pursuing action against the police is vital not only for the victim’s justice, but for safeguarding public trust and ensuring the legal system’s accountability.



Holding Power Accountable – The How


When police officers act unlawfully, their misconduct should not go unreported. Without formal checks or legal action, officers who abuse their position face no consequences and are more likely to continue acting in this manner, putting the community at risk. A harrowing example of complaints not acted on is in the case of the then Police Officer Wayne Couzens who despite complaints lodged, went on to falsely arrest, rape and murder Sarah Everard in 2021.



People who feel mistreated have two primary avenues to pursue accountability:



Formal Complaints of misconduct : Submitted directly to the force’s Professional Standards Department (PSD), complaints trigger internal investigations into officer behavior. If upheld, sanctions range from managerial guidance to dismissal. While complaints address individual discipline, they do not result in financial compensation for the victim. The PSD is overseen by the Independent Office of the Police



Civil Claims for Compensation: A civil action allows individuals to claim damages against the police force itself for civil wrongs such as unlawful arrest, false imprisonment, assault and battery, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, breaches of the Data Protection Act the Human Rights Act, the Equality Act & the Race Relations Act



Taking these routes forces the police force to examine internal procedures, disclose critical operational documents, and formally answer for the unlawful actions of its officers.





Breaking the cycle of police misconduct – The Why



Police misconduct can affect anyone regardless of age, sex, race, religion but some groups such as young males are systematically targeted for actions such as stop and search. By raising awareness of wrongful acts by Police officers, individuals are exposing unlawful actions, misconduct and patterns of bad practice that must be addressed. Raising this by making a complaint or pursuing a civil action, the person is highlighting a problem in the force that should be addressed for the sake of the community and protecting them from authoritative harm.



Things to consider when taking legal action against the Police



Understanding the legal process is essential when dealing with complaints against the Police. The below are some key points to understand:



Procedural Sequence: A civil claim cannot commence while criminal proceedings against the individual are ongoing. So if you are under investigation or have been charged with an offence by the Police you cannot start a claim against the police.



Complaint vs. Civil Claim: While a formal complaint can be filed alongside or prior to legal proceedings, a person is not required to make a complaint in order to bring a civil claim. Solicitors operating under Conditional Fee Agreements generally do not handle complaints directly, clients are often advised to manage complaints independently or focus their efforts on the civil claim.



The most common claims: The most frequent civil actions involve unlawful arrest, false imprisonment, unlawful stop and search and trespass to property.



Taking action against the police requires courage, but it remains one of the most effective tools for exposing unlawful actions of Police officers, securing fair compensation, and upholding the rule of law.

Rugby brain injury case delays: why medical evidence matters in serious injury claims

Hundreds of former rugby players pursuing claims for alleged brain injuries faced the loss of their cases this summer after repeated failures to disclose medical evidence. In August 2026, the High Court granted conditional relief from sanctions, allowing the affected claims to continue if strict requirements were met. An October hearing added significant costs and deadlines. The decisions do not establish whether the rugby authorities were negligent, but they demonstrate something relevant to any serious injury claim: medical evidence must be gathered, assessed and disclosed properly, and court orders must be followed.

What’s happening in the rugby brain injury litigation

The litigation began in 2022 and involves approximately 1,000 former players across rugby union and rugby league. Nearly 800 union players, including England’s 2003 World Cup winners Steve Thompson and Phil Vickery, have brought claims against World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and the Welsh Rugby Union. More than 300 former rugby league players are pursuing claims against the Rugby Football League and the British Amateur Rugby League Association. They allege that repeated concussive and sub-concussive impacts led to neurological injuries, including early-onset dementia and other conditions, and that the governing bodies failed to take reasonable protective measures.

These remain allegations, not findings of fact. The defendants deny liability, dispute whether the duties alleged were owed or breached, and challenge the medical evidence linking individual conditions to rugby. They also raise questions about the accepted risks of participation. The High Court’s recent judgments concern the handling of evidence and the progress of proceedings, not a decision on responsibility or compensation. Nor does an allegation of chronic traumatic encephalopathy establish that a living player has that condition; diagnosing it definitively remains difficult.

Why the case nearly collapsed this summer

Orders made from June 2024 required the claimants’ lawyers to disclose records from neurological testing, including interviews, brain scans and relevant assessments. Further orders with automatic strike-out consequences followed in 2025. By mid-2026, the defendants said substantial material was still missing and asked the court to confirm that more than 500 claims had been struck out. The central problem was procedural compliance with disclosure orders, not a judicial finding that the former players’ injuries were fabricated or that their claims lacked merit.

On 21 August 2026, reports stated that Mr Justice Jeremy Cook ruled in favour of allowing the affected claims to continue. The judgment was delivered by Senior Master Jeremy Cook, who found that 377 rugby union claims and 153 rugby league claims stood struck out under earlier orders, but granted relief from sanctions in principle. He regarded the individual players as blameless for their former lawyers’ failures and required outstanding disclosure and payment of the defendants’ enforcement costs. At a further hearing on 2 October, those costs were reported at over £2.8 million, with an immediate payment on account exceeding £1.5 million ordered. The proceedings remain subject to strict conditions, and the substantive allegations are unresolved.

Why medical evidence is so central to a claim

Medical evidence performs three important functions in a personal injury case. First, it helps establish causation: whether the incident or negligence caused the injury complained of. Second, it explains diagnosis and prognosis, including symptoms, recovery prospects and likely future difficulties. Third, it supports valuation by showing how the injury affects work, care, independence and everyday life. For a spinal injury, an amputation or a brain injury, future rehabilitation and support needs can be as significant as immediate treatment.

Medical reports used as expert evidence in civil proceedings are governed by Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The expert’s overriding duty is to assist the court objectively, not to argue for the person paying for the report. The court controls which expert evidence can be relied upon, and properly reasoned opinions must acknowledge relevant uncertainty. Clinical records and independent expert reports serve different purposes, but both may be essential.

What good medical evidence practice looks like

A relatively straightforward injury may need only one expert. Life-changing injuries often require several specialists to assess different physical, psychological and practical consequences, with the court’s permission where proceedings are under way.

Type of expertWhat their evidence typically establishes
Orthopaedic surgeonMusculoskeletal injuries, treatment and likely recovery
Neurologist or neuropsychologistNeurological symptoms, cognitive function and longer-term effects
Psychiatrist or psychologistPsychological injury, including PTSD or depression, where clinically supported
Care or occupational therapy expertFuture support, equipment, adaptations and care requirements
Employment or vocational expertEffects on employability, retraining and future earning capacity

The rugby proceedings show why delays in gathering and providing records can threaten a case even when the injured person has done nothing wrong. Attend reasonable assessments, describe symptoms and earlier medical history accurately, and respond promptly when your solicitor requests records or authorisations. Keep a diary of symptoms, treatment and practical limitations, and retain relevant correspondence. The Personal Injury Pre-Action Protocol encourages early information exchange, although different protocols may apply depending on the type and value of the claim. Full disclosure and compliance with court deadlines remain essential once proceedings begin.

Time limits and funding

In England and Wales, most adult personal injury proceedings must start within three years of the accident or a later date of knowledge, subject to exceptions, including for children and people who lack capacity. We handle eligible claims on a no win no fee basis. If your claim isn’t successful, you won’t pay us anything. If it is successful, our fee is 20% plus VAT (24% in total), taken from the compensation you receive for your pain and suffering and for financial losses up to settlement. We never take a fee from compensation for future losses, such as future care or loss of earnings, and nothing else is deducted from your compensation. We’ll confirm all of this in writing before your claim starts. Read why accident victims shouldn’t accept an offer before speaking to a lawyer, particularly before your long-term prognosis is clear.

Frequently asked questions

Here are answers to common questions about medical evidence in personal injury claims.

Who chooses the medical expert?

Your solicitor generally arranges appropriate experts. A single joint expert may be instructed where proportionate, particularly in less complex cases, but the court can allow separate specialists where necessary.

What if I disagree with what the medical report says?

Tell your solicitor about inaccuracies or overlooked evidence. Clarification questions can sometimes be sent to the expert. A further report may be appropriate, subject to the court’s rules and permission.

Can my claim be delayed if there’s a problem getting medical evidence together?

Yes. Missing records, postponed appointments or failure to comply with directions can delay proceedings and potentially lead to sanctions. The rugby litigation demonstrates how serious those consequences can become.

Do I need more than one medical report for a serious injury?

Often. A complex injury may require separate reports addressing physical injury, cognition, psychological effects, care needs and your ability to work, depending on the issues in dispute.

Will I have to attend a medical examination?

Usually, at least once. Additional assessments may be needed for different specialisms. Your solicitor should explain their purpose and help you prepare to provide an accurate medical history.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

Timely, independent medical evidence helps explain what an injury has changed and what support may be needed in future. Mark Reynolds Solicitors can help obtain appropriate reports, coordinate evidence and assess your claim without rushing settlement before the longer-term effects are understood. We assist clients throughout England and Wales and offer eligible claims on the funding terms explained above. Contact our team for a free, no-obligation conversation. Our offices are in Liverpool, Runcorn and Warrington.

What happens when a serious injury affects your ability to return to work

Returning to work after a serious injury depends on your recovery, the demands of your role and whether your employer can make suitable adjustments. Some people return gradually, perhaps with shorter hours or lighter duties. Others cannot safely resume their previous occupation, even after rehabilitation. Both outcomes matter when assessing a personal injury claim. Your ability to earn a living after the accident can have a greater financial impact than the award for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, especially when the injury ends a career early.

What a return to work usually looks like

If you’re off sick for more than seven consecutive calendar days, you’ll generally need a fit note, formally called a Statement of Fitness for Work. You can self-certify for the first seven days. Since July 2022, registered nurses, occupational therapists, pharmacists and physiotherapists, as well as doctors, have been authorised to issue fit notes where appropriate. The note may state that you’re unfit for work or that you may be fit with support, such as a phased return, altered hours, amended duties or workplace adaptations. Occupational health advice can help. Agree review dates, pay arrangements and what happens if the adjustments stop working.

A fit note gives medical advice rather than automatically changing your contract. Your employer should discuss any recommendations with you and consider appropriate adjustments, although not every suggestion will necessarily be practicable. If suitable changes cannot be agreed, you may be treated as unfit for work for the relevant period. GOV.UK’s guidance on sick leave explains the process, including longer absences and sick pay.

When your employer has to make reasonable adjustments

An injury may qualify as a disability under the Equality Act 2010 if it has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on normal day-to-day activities. Long-term generally means lasting, or likely to last, at least 12 months. Amputations, spinal injuries and lasting neurological damage can meet that definition, depending on their effects. The effects matter more than the diagnosis.

Where the legal test is met, employers must make reasonable adjustments to address disadvantages faced by disabled workers. Examples include specialist equipment, accessible workstations, amended tasks, flexible hours, additional breaks or suitable alternative vacancies. Reasonableness depends on factors such as effectiveness, practicality, cost and available resources. The duty generally arises when the employer knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, about the disability and disadvantage. Record your requests and consider occupational health advice. A refusal to make reasonable adjustments can amount to disability discrimination, regardless of intent.

When returning to your old job isn’t possible

Some injuries prevent a return to physically demanding work despite rehabilitation and reasonable adjustments. Alternatives may include redeployment, retraining for less demanding work or different hours. Ill-health retirement may be an option under a particular pension scheme, but it isn’t automatic and the financial implications need careful review. Medical and vocational evidence can establish realistic options.

You should not feel compelled to resign without advice. Dismissal or pressure to leave following an accident may raise employment-law issues, including unfair dismissal or discrimination. Our guide on whether you can be sacked after an accident at work explains those concerns, which can arise separately from your personal injury claim.

How this affects your compensation claim

Loss of earnings can be a substantial part of a serious injury settlement. Compensation may address pay already lost while you recovered and reduced income over your remaining working life. In a long-term claim, those financial losses may exceed damages for the injury itself, depending on medical and financial evidence. Pension and retraining costs may also matter.

You are expected to take reasonable steps to limit avoidable losses, but that does not mean accepting unsafe work or returning before you’re medically able. A suitable phased return, adjusted role or retraining may be relevant. Compensation is assessed on what you could reasonably earn with your injuries, not on an assumption that everyone can resume their previous employment. These examples illustrate the calculation.

Your situationWhat it typically means for your claim
Full recovery, same job and payPast net earnings lost during recovery, alongside damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity
Return to the same job and pay, but at a disadvantage if you ever lost itPossible compensation for a proven disadvantage on the open labour market, sometimes called a Smith v Manchester award
Return to work, but in a lower paid or lesser rolePast losses and a potential future earnings claim for the difference, where supported by evidence
Unable to return to work at allPast and potentially substantial future lost earnings and pension contributions, assessed against realistic working life and alternatives

Other losses may matter too. In suitable cases, someone who loses particularly fulfilling work may seek compensation for loss of congenial employment, although this is not an automatic award for changing jobs. A weakened position in the labour market must also be supported by evidence, rather than presumed from a diagnosis. Before accepting a settlement, read why accident victims shouldn’t accept an offer before speaking to a lawyer. Settlements are generally final, making an early valuation risky. Keep evidence of your lost earnings, including payslips, tax records, pension information, contracts and correspondence about your return. Expert evidence may help assess future earnings.

Protecting a larger settlement

If you receive substantial compensation and claim means-tested benefits, ask how the payment will be treated. Personal injury compensation is normally disregarded for Universal Credit during the first 12 months after receipt. After that, money held personally may affect entitlement. A properly established personal injury trust can preserve the relevant capital disregard, subject to benefit rules and correct administration. Discuss the arrangements before settlement funds are paid, particularly if you receive benefits. Different means-tested benefits have their own rules, so check your individual circumstances carefully before payment.

Time limits and funding

In England and Wales, most adult personal injury claims must be issued in court within three years of the accident or the later date of knowledge, subject to exceptions. Children and people lacking capacity can have different limits. Under our no win no fee basis, if your claim isn’t successful, you won’t pay us anything. If it is successful, our fee is 20% plus VAT (24% in total), taken from the compensation you receive for your pain and suffering and for financial losses up to settlement. We never take a fee from compensation for future losses, such as future care or loss of earnings, and nothing else is deducted from your compensation. We’ll confirm all of this in writing before your claim starts. Our guide to how the personal injury claim process works explains the stages.

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about work following a serious injury.

Do I have to go back to work if my employer offers me a role I don’t think I can do?

You don’t have to accept duties that are genuinely unsafe or unsuitable for your medical condition. Discuss the role, fit note and occupational health advice with your employer. Refusing suitable work without good reason may affect compensation; seek advice.

Can I still claim compensation if I’ve gone back to work on the same pay?

Yes. You may still claim damages for the injury and past losses. If your lasting condition creates a genuine disadvantage when seeking other employment, an additional award may be considered even though your current salary is unchanged.

What if I’m self-employed?

You may claim lost earnings or profit where supported by evidence. Tax returns, accounts, invoices and business records can establish the effect of the injury. Document lost business opportunities too.

Will claiming compensation affect my benefits?

It can affect means-tested benefits after the applicable temporary disregard. For Universal Credit, personal injury compensation is normally disregarded for 12 months; a properly administered personal injury trust may protect it afterwards. Get individual advice before receiving payment.

How is future loss of earnings actually calculated?

The calculation depends on your age, pre-injury earnings, likely retirement, medical prognosis and realistic future work. Solicitors may use Ogden actuarial tables and expert evidence.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

A serious injury may change when, how or whether you can work again, and the financial consequences deserve careful attention alongside rehabilitation. Mark Reynolds Solicitors can assess lost earnings, future employment prospects and the evidence needed before settlement. We offer no win, no fee funding on the terms explained above. Contact our team for a free, no-obligation conversation. We have offices in Liverpool, Runcorn and Warrington and can assist clients across England and Wales.

How home adaptations are valued after a life-changing injury

Home adaptations after a serious injury can range from installing grab rails and ramps to moving into a different, fully accessible property. Reasonable housing costs can form part of a personal injury claim. But valuing a more expensive home differs from ordinary adaptations, particularly after a Court of Appeal decision in 2020. That distinction matters for long-term planning.

What a home adaptations claim can cover

Smaller adaptations may include a ramp, grab rails, a stairlift or wider doorways. After a spinal injury or amputation, you might need a level-access bathroom, ground-floor bedroom, hoists, accessible kitchens or enough space for a wheelchair and carers. An extension or major alteration may be necessary. Following a severe brain injury, layout, supervision and safety requirements may be particularly important. Sometimes the existing house cannot reasonably be adapted, and a move to a more suitable property is the practical solution.

These expenses are generally considered special damages, the financial losses and expenses arising from an injury, rather than general damages for pain and suffering. Evidence of medical necessity, reasonable costs and future needs determines what can be recovered. Buying another property introduces a separate valuation problem because the home itself retains value.

Why the law doesn’t simply pay for a new house outright

Suppose your injury means you need a suitable home costing £200,000 more than you would otherwise have spent. It might seem that your compensation should automatically include the entire additional £200,000. The law considers another factor: the enduring value of the property.

A house is an asset that normally remains part of your estate. Unlike money used to pay carers or replace wages, its entire purchase price is not consumed through use. Awarding the whole additional capital sum could leave an asset worth more than the home you would have owned without the injury. The courts have therefore tried to compensate the extra housing need while avoiding an unintended financial windfall to your estate. That balance is difficult, particularly when suitable accommodation is essential to your independence and the money must be available when you need to buy.

How courts value additional accommodation costs today

For many years, the courts used the approach developed in Roberts v Johnstone in 1989. This calculated a notional annual investment return on the additional capital needed for housing, then valued that income stream over the injured person’s remaining life. It depended on the personal injury discount rate applicable at the time.

The approach became unworkable after the discount rate fell below zero in 2017. Applying a negative rate could produce no award under Roberts v Johnstone, even where a claimant had an established need for significantly more expensive accommodation. This created a serious problem: injured people could be forced to divert compensation intended for care, lost earnings or other essential expenses towards buying a suitable home.

In 2020, the Court of Appeal addressed this in Swift v Carpenter. Mrs Swift needed a property costing £900,000 more than the home she would otherwise have occupied, but the previous calculation had produced no accommodation award. The court instead calculated the additional capital cost and deducted the present value of the reversionary interest, reflecting the eventual value retained by the estate. It used an annual 5% rate to value that interest over a life expectancy of 45.43 years. This is the general approach for suitable cases, although the court recognised that different circumstances, including a short life expectancy, may require further consideration.

StepSwift v Carpenter example
Additional capital cost of suitable property£900,000
Value of the reversionary interest (5% rate over a 45.43 year life expectancy)£98,087
Accommodation award£801,913

The 5% valuation assumption in Swift v Carpenter is different from the statutory personal injury discount rate used to calculate lump-sum compensation for other future losses, including care and earnings. In England and Wales, that statutory rate increased from -0.25% to +0.5% on 11 January 2025; the change did not automatically alter the Swift calculation. Broadly, a shorter life expectancy means a greater present value for the reversionary interest and potentially a smaller accommodation award. Expert evidence on lifespan and housing requirements therefore matters, and a formula should not replace individual assessment.

Smaller adaptations and equipment

The Swift property-purchase method does not ordinarily govern costs such as grab rails, access ramps, stairlifts, hoists, adapted bathrooms or specialist seating. Those are usually assessed by reference to the reasonable cost of necessary work or equipment, together with installation, servicing and future replacement where justified. Some alterations may increase the property’s value, but that does not mean their reasonable costs are automatically excluded. Occupational therapists and building specialists can identify appropriate changes. Keep quotations, invoices, receipts and photographs, especially where you have already funded urgent work yourself.

The Disabled Facilities Grant: a different route

You may also qualify for a Disabled Facilities Grant from your local council towards necessary changes to your home. In England, the standard maximum is £30,000, although councils can provide discretionary additional assistance. Grants for adults are generally means tested, considering household income and savings above applicable thresholds. Occupational therapy and council assessments help establish which works are necessary and appropriate. Rules and maximum amounts differ elsewhere in the UK.

A grant can be valuable if urgent work is needed or no compensation claim is available. However, major adaptations or a move may cost considerably more than the standard grant limit. Do not assume a £30,000 grant will cover the full cost of an extension or accessible replacement property. A personal injury claim is assessed against proven losses and reasonable future needs, rather than a fixed grant ceiling. If public funding pays for work you also claim as damages, your solicitor should address potential overlap and the specific funding rules.

Getting adaptations funded before your claim settles

Serious injury claims often take considerable time to resolve, but urgent housing needs may arise much sooner. An interim payment can sometimes release part of the expected compensation before final settlement, helping pay for accessibility work, equipment or specialist assessments. The defendant may agree voluntarily; otherwise a court application must meet legal conditions, such as an admission of liability or sufficient evidence that substantial damages are likely. An interim payment is not guaranteed, and any amount is taken into account at settlement.

Early specialist input can identify changes improving safety and independence. Planning also reduces the risk of unsuitable alterations. Our guide to how the personal injury claim process works explains how evidence, rehabilitation and interim funding fit into a serious injury case.

Time limits and funding

For most adults in England and Wales, court proceedings must begin within three years of the accident or the relevant date of knowledge, subject to important exceptions. We handle eligible claims on a no win no fee basis. If your claim isn’t successful, you won’t pay us anything. If it is successful, our fee is 20% plus VAT (24% in total), taken from the compensation you receive for your pain and suffering and for financial losses up to settlement. We never take a fee from compensation for future losses, such as future care or loss of earnings, and nothing else is deducted from your compensation. We’ll confirm all of this in writing before your claim starts. Read why accident victims shouldn’t accept an offer before speaking to a lawyer before settling without a full accommodation assessment.

Frequently asked questions

Here are some common questions about housing adaptations, accessible accommodation and serious injury compensation.

Can I claim for a bigger house, not just adaptations to my current one?

Yes, if expert evidence shows that an alternative property is reasonably necessary because your existing home cannot meet your needs, or moving is more appropriate than extensive alterations. Additional accommodation capital is generally assessed using the Swift v Carpenter approach, considering your individual circumstances.

Do I have to pay the compensation back out of my estate when I die?

No. The reversionary interest is deducted when the accommodation award is calculated. It is not a separate debt automatically recoverable from your estate, and there is no routine repayment of the award on death.

Can I get a Disabled Facilities Grant and still bring a compensation claim?

Generally, yes. However, grants and compensation relating to the same adaptation work may need to be considered together to prevent double recovery. Tell your solicitor about any assistance awarded or applied for.

What if my needs change after my claim has settled?

Most settlements are full and final, so changing needs can be difficult to fund through a settled claim. Detailed medical, housing and occupational therapy evidence is important before settlement. Special settlement arrangements are possible in limited circumstances.

Do I need a case manager or occupational therapist to support this part of my claim?

For substantial adaptations, professional assessment is usually important. Occupational therapists identify functional needs, while accommodation experts and case managers can help assess suitable layouts, costs and future arrangements. The appropriate evidence depends on your injury and proposed work.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

Valuing home adaptations and alternative accommodation requires medical evidence, specialist costings and a clear understanding of your long-term needs. We can help assess the work required, seek suitable interim funding where available and make sure housing costs are considered before settlement. We represent eligible clients on a no win no fee basis, with terms confirmed in writing. Contact our team for a free, no-obligation conversation. Our offices are in Liverpool, Runcorn and Warrington, and we assist clients across England and Wales.

What a recent construction fall shows about serious spinal injuries at work

It was only his second week on the job. In January 2024, a 24-year-old labourer working for a scaffolding company on a West Yorkshire housing development stepped backwards through an unprotected stairwell opening and fell one storey onto concrete. He sustained serious spinal injuries and has not returned to physical work. The housebuilder, Hillbeck Homes (Sowerby Bridge) Ltd, was fined £300,000 in September 2026 after an HSE investigation identified failures in planning, supervision and fall prevention. The case illustrates how a familiar building-site hazard can cause life-changing injuries, and why responsibility for workplace safety may extend beyond the injured person’s direct employer.

What happened in Sowerby Bridge

A 24-year-old labourer and father of one was working temporarily for a scaffolding company on a site where Hillbeck Homes (Sowerby Bridge) Ltd was building four houses. The incident happened in January 2024, during his second week there. He stepped backwards through an opening intended for a staircase that had not yet been fitted and fell one storey onto the concrete floor below.

The stairwell opening had previously been covered by loose scaffold boards, but these had been removed, leaving no secure cover or protective barrier around the edges. There was no alternative access to the lower floor. The 24-year-old labourer lost consciousness in the fall and was rescued by West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service and a specialist Hazardous Area Response Team. His spinal injuries prevented him working for months, and HSE reported in September 2026 that he had not returned to a physically demanding job.

What HSE’s investigation found

The open stairwell posed a foreseeable fall risk. HSE found that Hillbeck Homes had not put adequate fall-prevention measures in place. The company was found guilty of three charges arising from failures to plan work at height properly, provide appropriate supervision and take suitable and sufficient precautions against falls. The investigation identified deficient site arrangements and missing physical safeguards.

Simple measures could have prevented the fall. Securing a properly designed cover over the opening, or installing suitable edge protection, would have addressed the exposed hazard. HSE Inspector Louise Redgrove described the incident as wholly avoidable and linked it to basic shortcomings in planning and supervision. A risk assessment on paper is not enough if the protective measures are removed and nobody ensures they are reinstated.

The legal outcome, and who was actually held responsible

On 16 September 2026, Leeds Magistrates’ Court fined Hillbeck Homes (Sowerby Bridge) Ltd £300,000 and ordered it to pay £9,284.05 in prosecution costs. HSE announced the outcome on 21 September 2026.

The 24-year-old labourer was employed by a scaffolding business, not Hillbeck Homes. Nevertheless, the prosecution was brought against the housebuilder responsible for the failures identified by HSE. This distinction matters: health and safety obligations can extend to workers employed by other organisations. A prosecution does not itself establish liability in a civil claim.

Construction work commonly involves developers, principal contractors, subcontractors and agency workers. Their duties depend on their roles and the activities or areas they control. Under the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015, principal contractors must coordinate health and safety during the construction phase, while individual contractors must manage risks arising from their own work. An employer’s duties also remain relevant. Our guide to employer duties under the Health and Safety at Work Act explains the wider framework. If an injured worker makes a civil claim, the evidence must show which parties owed a duty, how it was breached and whether that breach caused the injury.

The safety standard this case highlights

The Work at Height Regulations 2005 require work at height to be properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out safely by competent people. The hierarchy of control is to avoid work at height where reasonably practicable, prevent falls where the work cannot be avoided, and minimise the distance and consequences of any fall that cannot be prevented. They apply to floor openings as well as scaffolding and platforms.

Depending on the work, appropriate controls might include fixed or securely fitted covers, guardrails, barriers and safe access routes. Those protections must remain effective as trades move through the site. If a cover is temporarily removed, there needs to be a controlled system for protecting the opening and restoring the safeguards. Training and written instructions cannot substitute for suitable physical protection where it is reasonably practicable.

If you’ve suffered a spinal injury from a fall at work

Falls can involve open floors and roofs, missing edge protection, unsuitable ladders, defective working platforms or unguarded excavations. The important questions are whether the risk was foreseeable, who controlled the relevant work and what reasonable steps were taken to prevent it. A serious injury does not itself prove negligence, but failures in inspection, training, access arrangements or supervision may provide evidence of a breach of duty.

Do not assume your claim can only be against the business named on your payslip. An agency worker or subcontractor may have a potential claim against an employer, principal contractor or another party whose acts or omissions contributed to the accident. Responsibility is assessed individually, and more than one defendant may be involved. Our guide to making an accident at work claim explains the usual steps. Our article on which spinal injuries you can claim for discusses conditions ranging from spinal fractures and nerve damage to injuries causing permanent loss of mobility.

A spinal injury’s full effects may not be apparent immediately. Pain, neurological symptoms, rehabilitation needs and the ability to return to work can change over time. Medical evidence from an appropriate specialist may be needed before compensation can be assessed fairly, particularly where future treatment, care or earnings losses are involved. Our explanation of how the personal injury claim process works outlines this process. Preserve photographs, incident reports, medical records and witnesses’ details, and record how your symptoms affect daily life and employment.

Time limits and funding

In England and Wales, most adult personal injury claims must be brought within three years of the accident or the later date of knowledge, with exceptions. An HSE investigation or prosecution does not stop this clock. Different rules can apply to children and people lacking litigation capacity. We offer eligible claims on a no win no fee basis, with no upfront solicitor’s fee. We explain possible deductions and costs before you sign.

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about spinal injuries following falls at work.

I wasn’t employed directly by the company controlling the site. Can I still claim against them?

Potentially, yes. A principal contractor or another business controlling the relevant work may owe legal duties to people employed by other organisations. Whether you have a claim depends on the duties owed, the evidence of any breach and whether it caused your injury.

If HSE prosecutes my employer or the site controller, do I still need my own claim?

Yes. A criminal prosecution concerns breaches of safety law, and any fine is not compensation paid to the injured worker. To recover damages for injury, lost earnings or care needs, you normally need a separate civil claim, whether settled by agreement or decided by a court.

How serious does a fall have to be before I can claim?

There is no minimum height. What matters is whether another party breached a duty of care and caused a compensable injury. Even short falls can cause serious harm.

Can I claim if I was partly at fault, for example if I stepped somewhere I shouldn’t have?

Possibly. An employer or other dutyholder may still be responsible for failing to protect a foreseeable hazard. If you contributed to the accident, a court may reduce damages for contributory negligence. The outcome depends on the evidence; responsibility is not decided solely by where you stepped.

How long does a spinal injury claim usually take?

There is no standard timescale. Claims involving severe or uncertain spinal injuries may take longer because medical specialists need to assess recovery, care requirements and future losses. Liability disputes and rehabilitation can also affect the timetable. Some cases resolve sooner, while complex claims may take years.

Talk to Mark Reynolds Solicitors

This case shows why preventing falls is essential and why safety responsibilities can extend beyond a worker’s direct employer. If you or someone close to you has suffered a spinal injury after a fall at work, including at a construction site operated by another business, Mark Reynolds Solicitors can assess the circumstances and explain who may be responsible. We handle eligible cases on a no win no fee basis, with terms explained at the outset. We take instructions from clients nationwide and have offices in Liverpool, Leigh, Runcorn and Warrington. Call us on 0800 002 9577 to speak to our team.